Molotovs Magic Lantern: A Journey in Russian History by Rachel Polonsky: review
By Charlotte Hobson 620AM GMT thirteen March 2010
Molotov"s Magic Lantern A Journey in Russian History by Rachel Polonsky In the Nineties, Rachel Polonsky lived in an unit retard still referred to by Muscovites as "the Party Archive" from the years as a lazy place for Communist Party officials. On the building on top of hers lay Vyacheslav Molotovs old flat, with his Stalin-era seat and the stays of his book collection, annotated and catalogued by the owners in violet ink. It turns out that the antipathetic Molotov who sealed off some-more names for execution during the purges than Stalin, and of whom Stalin remarked (rather wittily) "If Molotov did not exist, it would be required to invent him" was a ardent book collector, who review communication and whose prime bard was Chekhov.
There is a dispiriting thesis in Polonskys book, of cultivated, well-read people who dedicate distressing crimes the Nazi co-operator and probable fight rapist Boris Filistinsky who later, underneath the name Filippov, had a prolonged and reputable career as a writer and editor at an American university; and the violent and learned Baron Ungern-Sternberg, in between others. What is one to have of these characters, who love the humanities, and epitomize inhumanity?
This is usually one strand of majority in this unenlightened but erotically appealing skatulochka trinket box of Russian history. Also in Molotovs unit is a sorcery lantern, for that Polonsky finds an apposite selection from Anna Akhmatova "Memory is structured so that, similar to a projector, it illuminates dissimilar moments, withdrawal resolute dim all around." Molotov has a terrifying genius to forget. When questioned in after hold up about those whose lives he sealed away, infrequently thousands in a day, he is deceptive "I cant remember… I think he got churned up with the Right-wingers… What does it matter?" Much of � la mode Russia seems happy to cooperate with this amnesia. Yet this book celebrates those couple of who exclude to forget, and whose efforts illuminate even the darkest moments of the past.
As Polonsky travels in widening circles afar from Moscow, down to Taganrog in the south, Arkhangelsk and Murmansk in the north, she encounters the dim side of Russian history. The picture of a "Lend-Lease" American bulldozer shovelling solidified corpses in to a Gulag grave is one that will stay with me for a little time, as will Boris Epsteins distinguished research of the demoniac "labour lust" that authorised the rape of the Russian landscape "Its traces sojourn on the faces of the cities and villages… in the gullies and potholes on the physique of the tired land." The good chronicler of the Gulag, Varlam Shalamov, observes Moscow ringed by towerblocks "like watchtowers, guarding the prisoners", and draws the staid finish that "the watchtower of the Gulag section was the architectural pitch the principal thought of his time".
Yet there is light, too, and beauty. Polonskys outline of the far north of Russia finished me prolonged to visit, with the "other-worldly" landscape in that the colours of the H2O and the sky shift notation by notation and the suggestion universe is near. The historian Likhachev, a domestic restrained in Solovki, unexpected "found himself sitting on a stone in the sun, intuiting God, benefaction but unknowable. At that impulse a stay ensure who would… have shot the wandering prisoner, lowered his gun." These dual survivors became friends, analogous years later, still usually means to impute to one side to their years in the Gulag. At least, as Polonsky notes, "in the prison-house of the universe we are not alone".
Much of Molotovs Magic Lantern can be review as an paper to books and reading. The 19th-century reflective thinker and librarian Fyodorov believed that "to investigate meant not to scolding and not to praise, but to revive life" both to subjects and to readers. In Soviet times majority were postulated by study, anticipating resourceful ways to plead banned preoccupations. Polonsky records that "to write about Tsar Nicholas I and the Decembrists [officers who attempted a manoeuvre opposite him], even in sentences walled in by divine quotations from Lenin, was to write about tyranny, and the goal for probity and domestic freedom". Shalamov describes the craving for books that is roughly as intolerable as the heedfulness of starvation. "There is no sweeter thing," he said, "than the steer of an unread book." Later he remade his pang in to bright prose, utterly as skilful as Chekhovs. One wishes that Molotov had been forced to review it, nonetheless no disbelief he would have responded with his common mulishness "1937 was necessary."
Polonsky is an zealous collector, amused by oddities and disposed to shopping books usually given she feels contemptible for them laid out on cosmetic in a petrify underpass. Her interests are eclectic, trimming from problematic 19th-century poets to � la mode promotion pamphlets. The latter she fillets with dry quick mind upsetting publications sponsored by the FSB that spell out Russias primal supremacy, and the Roerich Movements New Age prophecies, "rich in pseudoscience", that advise of risk from Europe, "noting in flitting that the object sets in the west and scenes of the Apocalypse crop up on the horse opera walls of Russian churches". Contemporary governing body does not unequivocally seductiveness her, but by sifting by the layers of madness and influence in Russian enlightenment she achieves a some-more surpassing bargain of Putins Russia than majority alternative unfamiliar observers.
Describing the landscape around Novgorod, Polonsky uses the word toska "melancholy, containing shades of yearning, nostalgia, even anguish", as she orderly defines it. There is toska aplenty on this tour by the Russian common memory, and the claustrophobic clarity of themes encircling by time, never utterly resolved. "History does not move forward. It moves not in a line, nor a circle, but in an arabesque, that is not regularly a line of beauty," writes Polonsky.
But there is a clarity that the law exists, even if it goes abandoned by most. Near the finish of the book, Molotov admits he infrequently dreams of Stalin. "Im in a little kind of broken city and I cant find any approach out… thereafter I encounter with him." It is frequency a reimburse for the thousands he sent to their deaths. Yet as Polonsky says "In a little low microgroove of his distressing mind, Molotov sensed that what he and Stalin had finished together had something to do with destruction."
Forty years or some-more have upheld given the purges; Soviet energy has fallen. Meanwhile, on the southern steppe, total civilisations Scythian, Greek, Mongol distortion dark underneath the grasses that run on, unbroken, in to the lilac-coloured distance. Molotovs prosaic is right afar inhabited by a TV writer and his glamorous wife, who have redecorated in the new Russian style. Perhaps it will take usually time to heal the wounds that men such as Molotov inflicted on Russia. Polonsky chooses this selection from Herzen for the books epigraph "Lives, people, revolutions, dear faces have appeared, altered and dead in between the Sparrow Hills and Primrose Hill; already their traces have been roughly swept away."
Molotovs Magic Lantern a Journey in Russian History by Rachel Polonsky 388pp, Faber & Faber, �20
Buy right afar for �18 (PLUS �1.25 p&p) 0844 871 1515 or from Books
Buy Molotov"s Magic Lantern, right afar at Book Shop
